A few things. The price of the phones you listed above, even in contract, on ebay. Are to high of price. I can get a 700wx for 100 bucks average. And treos do have built in keyboards. Your looking at 300 bucks on ebay at least, for the xv6800. The xv6800's screen is a wide screen version of treos screen. 240x320. Now you have moving parts (sliding keyboard), which only God knows some people CANT have. And they both run the same operating system. Theres a TON more features out their for the Treo compared to the xv6800. So...if the only thing I get is a longer/wider (how ever you wana look at it) screen, for 200 dollars more. O ok, the xv6800 has built in wifi. Ya I can add that for 40 bucks. So...if I all I get for the 6800 is a wider screen for 200 dollars more (used), 300 dollars (new), wifi, and bigger keyboard. I would have to say no.
Treo is 2.28x4.44x0.9 and the 6800 is 4.3x2.3x0.7, I can deal with the two tenths of an inch thicker